Saturday, November 21, 2026

Amadeus, Aquinas, and the parable of the talents

If I could recommend but one movie about classical music, it would be the 1984 film Amadeus, directed by Miloš Forman, which won 8 Academy Awards including Best Picture. The plot follows a popular myth that the great composer Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart was poisoned by fellow composer Antonio Salieri, who was said to be bitterly envious of Mozart. While music historians have since debunked that myth, it does still make for a great movie!

Mozart’s popular middle name, “Amadeus,” actually means “loved by God,” from the Latin ama (love) and Deus (God). Mozart’s baptismal name was Johannes Chrysostomus Wolfgangus Theophilus Mozart—Johannes Chrysostomus being his customary Catholic saint’s name (Mozart’s birthday was January 27, the feast day of St. John Chrysostom), and Theophilus being Greek for “loved by God.” As an aside, I am still totally bummed that my parents never gave me a saint’s name…

 

So why do I bring up the movie Amadeus? Well, a large part of the drama that drives the movie comes from the depiction of Antonio Salieri’s envy and resentment toward Mozart. Salieri (as so compellingly portrayed by actor F. Murray Abraham) ultimately blames God, accusing God of unfairly imbuing Mozart with much greater talent while depriving him of the same. In one scene, Salieri says, “All I ever wanted was to sing to God. He gave me that longing… and then made me mute. Why? Tell me that. If He didn’t want me to praise Him with music, why implant the desire? Like a lust in my body! And then deny me the talent?”

 

Well, first we must address some inaccuracies in movie Salieri’s accusation (I say “movie Salieri” as opposed to the historical Salieri, who was on quite good terms with Mozart). He did have talent; he was by no means “mute.” In fact, he was quite an established composer during his time. He just wasn’t as good as Mozart, but that’s not the same as being talentless. That said, envy does have a way of affecting one’s perception, and I will admit that I’ve had my fair share of colleagues whom I have envied—I mean, don’t even get me started on “perfect Beverly” haha! Who is perfect Beverly, you ask? That’s a story for another day, dear reader! But I suppose most of us might have at some point asked, “why does God impart greater abilities to some more than others?”

 

And whenever we have a gripping theological question, good ol’ Thomas Aquinas very often has answers. Regarding the question of unequal abilities, Aquinas writes (and don’t worry, there’s a “plain English” version following this quotation):

 

For He brought things into being in order that His goodness might be communicated to creatures, and be represented by them; and because His goodness could not be adequately represented by one creature alone, He produced many and diverse creatures, that what was wanting to one in the representation of the divine goodness might be supplied by another. For goodness, which in God is simple and uniform, in creatures is manifold and divided and hence the whole universe together participates the divine goodness more perfectly, and represents it better than any single creature whatever.

- St. Thoams Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, Ia q47 a1, emphasis mine

 

In plain English, Aquinas is saying that God intended for all of us to be diverse, such that we could share His goodness with each other by supplying to each person what they lack. This makes sense especially if we consider the alternative: if no one lacked anything, then everyone would basically be God, and, well, that just wouldn’t make sense, right? Now, might movie Salieri’s envy have been assuaged if he had simply read more Aquinas? Haha, I’m not so sure! Having read my fair share of Aquinas, I must confess that simply having an intellectual answer to an emotional question is not some kind of magical antidote.

 

All that said, I think this idea of diverse individuals exchanging gifts to supplement what the other lacks is a great way to think of the parable of the talents (where, in that context, a talent referred to a large amount of money), and Jesus does speak of the servants in the parable going out to trade. Origen of Alexandria spoke about this exchanging of gifts in the context of teaching and learning from one another:

 

Or, They that have their senses exercised by healthy conversation, both raising themselves to higher knowledge and zealous in teaching others, these have gained other five; because no one can easily have increase of any virtues that are not his own, and without he teaches others what he himself knows, and no more.

- Origen in Thomas Aquinas' Catena Aurea, commentary on Matthew 25

 

In plain English, Origen is saying that we grow in virtue primarily by learning it from others, hence each person has a responsibility to both teach and learn. So, if you’re wondering, did Carlo learn much from that “perfect Beverly” character he mentioned earlier? Oh, dear reader, I learned soooooooo very much from her… But as I’ve said, that is a story for another day!

 

With my peace,

Carlo Serrano, Music Director

No comments:

Post a Comment

Amadeus, Aquinas, and the parable of the talents

If I could recommend but one movie about classical music, it would be the 1984 film Amadeus , directed by Miloš Forman, which won 8 Academy ...